Italy’s Antitrust Watchdog Accuses Apple Of Abusing Its Market Dominance Against Third-Party App Developers
In the wake of the recent banning of ChatGPT and the resultant spike in VPN service downloads, another American tech giant is under scrutiny in Italy, this time for allegedly abusing its market dominance against third-party app developers. The company in question is none other than Apple.
The Italian Competition Garante, the country’s antitrust watchdog, has accused Apple of applying more restrictive and disadvantageous data privacy policies to non-Apple apps since April 2021. According to a press release by the agency, Apple competitors are required to display a prompt that asks users to consent to tracking in a more relevant position than the one to deny the practice, and this prompt is also reported to employ misleading language about online tracking activities. The watchdog’s investigation has been opened to probe such allegations.
Contents
Apple’s Alleged Abuse of Market Dominance
The antitrust watchdog AGCM has accused Apple of alleged discriminatory conduct, which may cause a drop in advertising revenue from third-party advertisers, to the benefit of its commercial division. This conduct may also reduce entry and/or prevent competitors from remaining in the app development and distribution market and benefit Apple’s own apps and mobile devices, including the Apple iOS operating system.
The watchdog has specifically accused Apple of applying more restrictive and disadvantageous data privacy policies to non-Apple apps. The company allegedly displays prompts to ask users to consent to tracking of their ‘navigation’ data on the web, and the tools adopted to measure the effectiveness of advertising campaigns are also reportedly employed with different treatment. The different treatment is mainly based on the characteristics of the prompt that appears to users to acquire consent to the tracking of their ‘navigation’ data on the web. This is a practice that, according to the watchdog, only Apple competitors are required to display the prompt to asking user consent for tracking in more relevant position compared to the one to deny the practice.
Furthermore, third-party developers appear to be disadvantaged by the quality and details that Apple gives them out about their ad campaigns. This, according to the watchdog, is due to the alleged discriminatory conduct by Apple.
Apple’s Response
Apple has rejected the allegations made against it and has argued that it imposes the same privacy rules to all developers, including Apple itself. The company has issued a statement saying, “We will continue to engage constructively with the AGCM to address any of their questions.”
Antitrust Investigations in Europe
This is not the first time that Apple has come under antitrust investigation in Europe. Since the company launched its App Tracking Transparency (ATT) feature two years ago, a number of complaints and probes have been filed over alleged abuses. In March 2021, a French startup lobby group raised the alarm over Apple’s privacy dishonesty, and similar concerns were also raised in Germany and Poland. In the same year, the UK expressed concerns over the growing dominance of Apple’s market power overall.
Implications for the Tech Industry
The investigation into Apple’s alleged abuse of market dominance has significant implications for the tech industry. If the allegations are found to be true, this could lead to changes in the way that tech giants operate, particularly with regard to their market power and the way they treat third-party developers.
The Digital Markets Act, which is currently being considered by the European Parliament, is aimed at regulating the behavior of tech giants like Apple, Amazon, Facebook, and Google. The legislation would require these companies to share data with their competitors, allow users to uninstall pre-installed apps, and follow specific rules when promoting their services.
The accusations against Apple by the Italian watchdog have drawn attention to the issue of market dominance and the control that large tech companies have over the app development industry. The allegations, if proven, could have serious implications for Apple and its competitors in the tech industry.
The issue of data privacy and tracking has become increasingly important in recent years, and tech companies are facing greater scrutiny over their handling of user data. The Italian watchdog’s investigation into Apple’s alleged abuse of market dominance is just one example of the growing concern over data privacy and the need for greater transparency in the tech industry.
It remains to be seen how Apple will respond to the allegations, but the company has previously faced similar accusations in other countries. In 2020, Apple was fined €1.1 billion by the French antitrust watchdog for anticompetitive practices, including allegedly abusing its market dominance to favor its own products and services over those of its rivals.
The Italian investigation is ongoing, and it will be interesting to see what conclusions the watchdog comes to. The outcome of the investigation could have significant implications for the wider tech industry, particularly as other countries may follow Italy’s lead and launch their own investigations into the practices of large tech companies.
In conclusion, the allegations against Apple by the Italian watchdog highlight the growing concern over market dominance and data privacy in the tech industry. The outcome of the investigation could have significant implications for Apple and the wider tech industry, and it will be interesting to see how the company responds to the allegations.
